Freshpet Review 2026

by

Freshpet Review 2026: Refrigerated Fresh Food at Retail

GetPetPros Score: 7.9/10

Category Score
Ingredient Quality 8.0/10
Nutritional Completeness 8.0/10
Convenience 9.0/10
Value for Money 7.5/10
Palatability 9.0/10
Ingredient Transparency 7.5/10

Quick verdict: Freshpet is uniquely positioned as a refrigerated fresh food available at retail stores — no subscription required. This gives it unmatched convenience among fresh dog foods. The ingredient quality is better than standard kibble but doesn’t quite match the human-grade credentials of Farmer’s Dog or PetPlate. Best for owners who want fresh food without subscription commitment.

Best for: Owners who want fresh food without subscriptions, dogs who won’t eat dry kibble, households who shop at Petco/PetSmart/Walmart regularly.
Not ideal for: Large dogs (cost becomes significant), owners needing precise nutritional calibration, dogs with complex health needs.

Check Price“>Shop Freshpet →

Company Overview

Freshpet was founded in 2006 in Secaucus, New Jersey by Scott Morris, Cathal Walsh, and Barry Rafferty. The company went public (FRPT) in 2014 and has grown to become one of the fastest-growing pet food brands in the United States. Unlike subscription fresh food brands, Freshpet sells through an extensive retail refrigeration network — over 30,000 refrigerators in Petco, PetSmart, Walmart, Target, and grocery stores. This retail-first approach is their core differentiation.

Key differentiators:

  • Available in over 30,000 retail locations — no subscription required
  • Refrigerated format (not frozen) — ready to serve from the store
  • Multiple formats: rolls (slice and serve), bags (ready portions), complete meal trays
  • U.S.-manufactured in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
  • Publicly traded company (FRPT on Nasdaq)

Product Lineup

Vital (Grain-Free)

  • Chicken Roll
  • Beef & Bison Roll
  • Multi-Protein Roll

Select (Grain-Inclusive)

  • Chicken & Rice Roll
  • Beef & Barley Roll
  • Small Dog Select (grain-inclusive)

Nature’s Fresh (Complete Meals)

Pre-portioned bags. Turkey & Beef, Chicken.

Homestyle Creations

Kibble-mixed format (dry kibble + fresh refrigerated protein).

Pricing:
| Product | Size | ~Price |
|———|——|——–|
| Vital Chicken Roll | 5.5 lb roll | $22–$26 |
| Select Chicken & Rice Roll | 5.5 lb roll | $20–$24 |
| Nature’s Fresh Turkey & Beef | 1.75 lb bag | $8–$10 |

Ingredient Analysis

Select Chicken & Rice Roll:

Key ingredients: Chicken, chicken liver, chicken heart, brown rice, carrots, spinach, eggs, water, salt, vitamins and minerals

Positives:

  • Chicken as first ingredient (whole muscle)
  • Chicken liver and heart — organs that provide natural B vitamins and minerals
  • Brown rice as grain carbohydrate — no legume concerns
  • Eggs as secondary protein source
  • Spinach and carrots for nutrients
  • Simple, readable ingredient list

Concerns:

  • “Water” and “salt” as ingredients are normal for fresh format but worth noting
  • Vitamin/mineral mix is broader than premium subscription brands
  • Select line uses carrageenan (seaweed-derived thickener) in some wet formulas — some owners avoid this

Pricing Breakdown

| Dog Size | Daily Cost |
|———-|———–|
| Small (15 lbs) | $2.00–$2.80 |
| Medium (40 lbs) | $4.50–$6.00 |
| Large (70 lbs) | $7.00–$9.00 |

Freshpet is more expensive than kibble and can approach the cost of subscription fresh food brands for medium/large dogs — without the subscription discount benefits.

Pros

  • Available at 30,000+ retail locations without subscription
  • Refrigerated format preferred by many picky dogs
  • Simple, whole-food ingredient lists
  • High palatability — excellent for transitioning from kibble
  • Grain-inclusive options in Select line

Cons

  • Expensive per pound compared to subscription fresh food brands
  • Not human-grade certified (not USDA-inspected human-grade kitchen)
  • Less nutritionally precise than subscription brands with individualized portioning
  • Short refrigerator shelf life after opening (5–7 days)

Who Is Freshpet Best For?

Freshpet is ideal for the owner who wants fresh food’s palatability and ingredient profile without subscribing to a delivery service. It’s particularly useful for dogs who reject kibble but whose owners aren’t ready to commit to a fresh food subscription. The retail presence makes it a practical topper option — add a slice of Freshpet roll to kibble to dramatically improve palatability and add some whole-food nutrition.

Alternatives

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Freshpet safe?

A: Freshpet has had recalls — including a 2022 recall of specific lots of dog food due to salmonella contamination. As with any fresh/refrigerated food, proper handling (refrigerate promptly, don’t leave out) is important. The brand has an ongoing safety testing program.

Q: How long does Freshpet last after opening?

A: Freshpet rolls last approximately 7 days after cutting in the refrigerator. Sealed rolls are good until the “use by” date. Do not freeze; the texture breaks down.

Q: Is Freshpet a complete and balanced food?

A: Yes — all Freshpet formulas are formulated to meet AAFCO nutritional standards for their labeled life stage.

Q: Where is Freshpet made?

A: Freshpet is manufactured at their facility in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania (Freshpet Village), which is a dedicated fresh pet food facility. They also have a second kitchen in Ennis, Texas.

GetPetPros.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment