Pumpkin vs Lemonade Pet Insurance (2026)
Quick Verdict
| Category | Pumpkin | Lemonade |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 8.4/10 | 8.4/10 |
| Monthly Cost (avg dog) | ~$30–$60/month | ~$20–$60/month |
| Reimbursement Model | 90% reimbursement; annual deductible; preventive rider | 70–90% reimbursement; annual; AI claims |
| Best For | 90% reimbursement fixed, preventive care included | Lowest premium, AI claims, modular |
Brand Overview
Pumpkin: Pumpkin (2020) offers 90% reimbursement as standard on all plans—no choosing. Includes a Preventive Essentials add-on covering vaccines and annual exams. Backed by Chubb (one of the world’s largest insurers).
Lemonade: Lemonade is a tech-first insurer with the lowest premiums in the market. AI-driven claims, modular add-ons for preventive/dental/behavioral. B-Corp.
Coverage Comparison
| Coverage Item | Pumpkin | Lemonade |
|---|---|---|
| Accidents | Yes | Yes |
| Illnesses | Yes | Yes |
| Hereditary | Yes | Yes |
| Preventive Add-on | Yes (Preventive Essentials) | Yes (tiered packages) |
| Dental Illness | No | Optional add-on |
| Reimbursement | 90% (fixed) | 70–90% (choosable) |
| Annual Limit | $10K or unlimited | $10K–$100K |
Pricing Snapshot
| Pet Profile | Pumpkin | Lemonade |
|---|---|---|
| Dog, 2 years | ~$30–$50/month | ~$20–$40/month |
| Cat, 2 years | ~$15–$25/month | ~$12–$20/month |
Pros and Cons
Pumpkin
Pros
- 90% reimbursement—no choice needed, always the best rate
- Preventive Essentials covers vaccines and exams
- Backed by Chubb (strong financial backing)
- Clean, simple app-based experience
Cons
- Less flexible than Lemonade (no dental/behavioral add-ons)
- Newer brand (2020)
- Higher premium than Lemonade
Lemonade
Pros
- Lowest premiums
- AI instant claims
- Dental and behavioral optional
- B-Corp giving model
Cons
- Must select reimbursement rate (default may be lower)
- Less established
Best For
Choose Pumpkin if: You want the simplicity of always-90% reimbursement without choosing, backed by Chubb’s financial strength.
Choose Lemonade if: You want the lowest premium with AI-driven claims and modular add-on flexibility.
Alternatives
- [Pumpkin vs Embrace](/compare/pumpkin-vs-embrace)
- [Lemonade vs Pets Best](/compare/lemonade-vs-pets-best)
- [Full Pumpkin Review](/reviews/pumpkin-pet-insurance)
FAQ
Is Pumpkin always 90% reimbursement?
Yes. Pumpkin’s model is simple: 90% reimbursement on all eligible claims. No choosing between 70%, 80%, or 90% tiers.
Does Lemonade or Pumpkin have better preventive care?
Both offer preventive care add-ons. Pumpkin’s Preventive Essentials is straightforward. Lemonade has tiered packages with more flexibility.
Which is newer?
Pumpkin launched in 2020. Lemonade’s pet insurance launched in 2019.
Is Chubb a good insurer?
Chubb is one of the world’s largest and most financially stable insurers. Having Chubb as Pumpkin’s backer is a strong financial assurance.
Does Pumpkin cover dental?
Pumpkin covers dental accidents but not dental illness. Lemonade offers dental illness as an optional add-on.
*Disclosure: GetPetPros.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’ve independently evaluated.*