Open Farm vs Ollie Dog Food (2026): Ethical Sourcing vs Gourmet Fresh
Quick Verdict
| Category | Open Farm | Ollie |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 8.7/10 | 8.8/10 |
| Delivery Model | Subscription + retail, traceable sourcing | Subscription fresh delivery (gourmet) |
| Price (monthly avg) | ~$70–$160/month | ~$70–$200/month |
| AAFCO Compliant | Yes | Yes |
| Best For | Farm traceability, ethical sourcing, kibble to fresh spectrum | Personalized gourmet fresh, palatability-focused |
Brand Overview
Open Farm was founded in 2014 in Canada and stands out for its radical transparency: every bag/can/pouch includes a TraceBack code you can use to see exactly which farms your food came from. Open Farm covers everything from kibble to gently cooked fresh to raw freeze-dried.
Ollie (2016) delivers personalized human-grade gourmet fresh meals on subscription. Recipes developed with veterinary nutritionists. Uses USDA-grade proteins from family farms.
Ingredient Comparison
Open Farm Gently Cooked Turkey & Salmon features pasture-raised turkey, wild-caught salmon, sweet potato, lentils, kale, and a complete vitamin/mineral blend. All ingredients are humanely raised and traceable.
Ollie Turkey recipe features turkey, turkey liver, sweet potatoes, carrots, kale, blueberries, flaxseed oil, salmon oil, and a vitamin/mineral complex.
Nutritional Comparison
| Nutrient | Open Farm Gently Cooked Turkey | Ollie Turkey |
|---|---|---|
| Crude Protein (min) | 12% | 12% |
| Crude Fat (min) | 6% | 6% |
| Moisture (max) | 72% | 72% |
| Calories (per oz) | ~33 | ~38 |
Pros and Cons
Open Farm
Pros
- TraceBack code—full farm traceability for every ingredient
- Humanely raised and certified sourcing
- Covers full product spectrum (kibble, wet, gently cooked, raw)
- Available at some retail locations (Petco, independent stores)
- Excellent for ethics-conscious owners
Cons
- Gently cooked line is pricier than some competitors
- Less personalized than Ollie’s profiling system
- Newer fresh line—less track record than Ollie
Ollie
Pros
- Personalized portions based on dog’s exact profile
- Strong palatability—popular with picky eaters
- Vet nutritionist-developed recipes
- Proven multi-year subscription service
Cons
- Less farm traceability than Open Farm
- No kibble or retail option
- Premium pricing for large dogs
Best For
Choose Open Farm if: Ethical sourcing and supply chain transparency matter to you, and you want the flexibility of multiple product formats.
Choose Ollie if: You want personalized fresh meals with maximum palatability and convenience.
Alternatives
- [JustFoodForDogs vs Ollie](/compare/justfoofordogs-vs-ollie)
- [Freshpet vs Ollie](/compare/freshpet-vs-ollie)
- [Full Open Farm Review](/reviews/open-farm-dog-food)
FAQ
What is Open Farm’s TraceBack feature? Every Open Farm product includes a TraceBack code on the bag. Enter it at openfarmpet.com/traceback to see the specific farms, fisheries, and suppliers used in your product batch.
Is Open Farm available in stores? Yes. Open Farm kibble and some wet food is available at Petco and independent pet stores. The gently cooked fresh line is primarily online/subscription.
How does Ollie personalize portions? You enter your dog’s age, weight, breed, activity level, and body condition. Ollie’s algorithm calculates daily caloric needs and pre-portions packs accordingly.
Are both brands truly human-grade? Open Farm’s gently cooked line is human-grade. Their kibble is made with human-grade ingredients but processed in a pet food facility. Ollie is fully human-grade processed.
Which is better for dogs with allergies? Open Farm has a full product range including LID options. Ollie’s rotation of recipes can help identify triggers but isn’t specifically designed for elimination diets.
*Disclosure: GetPetPros.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’ve independently evaluated.*