Instinct vs Blue Buffalo Dog Food (2026)
Quick Verdict
| Category | Instinct | Blue Buffalo |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 8.8/10 | 7.8/10 |
| Ingredient Quality | Premium | Good |
| Price (avg bag) | ~$85–$100/22 lb | ~$55–$65/30 lb |
| AAFCO Compliant | Yes | Yes |
| Best For | Raw-infused, very high protein | Affordable natural, LifeSource Bits |
Overview
Instinct (Nature’s Variety, Lincoln NE) produces raw-coated kibble and freeze-dried raw formulas at 37% protein. Raw Boost adds freeze-dried raw pieces to kibble. Premium positioning.
Blue Buffalo (General Mills) is America’s best-selling natural brand with LifeSource Bits, True Blue Promise, and wide availability at a lower price.
Ingredient Comparison
Instinct Original features cage-free chicken first, chicken meal, turkey meal. Raw-coated. No grain, corn, wheat, soy. 37% protein, 20% fat.
Blue Buffalo LPF features deboned chicken first. LifeSource Bits. No by-products, corn, wheat, soy. 24% protein.
Nutritional Snapshot
| Nutrient | Instinct Original Chicken | Blue Buffalo LPF Adult |
|---|---|---|
| Crude Protein (min) | 37% | 24% |
| Crude Fat (min) | 20% | 14% |
| Calories (kcal/cup) | ~475 | ~368 |
Pros and Cons
Instinct
Pros
- 37% protein—exceptional
- Raw-coated for raw nutrition benefits
- Cage-free chicken and turkey
- No grain, corn, wheat, soy
- Raw Boost option for added variety
Cons
- Expensive (~$85–$100/22 lb)
- Very high caloric density—careful portioning needed
- Limited life-stage variety
Blue Buffalo
Pros
- Much more affordable
- LifeSource Bits antioxidant blend
- Wide variety across all life stages
- Wide retail distribution
Cons
- Much lower protein (24% vs 37%)
- Multiple recalls 2017–2019
- General Mills ownership
Best For
Choose Instinct if: You want raw-infused high-protein nutrition for an active or performance dog.
Choose Blue Buffalo if: Affordable natural nutrition with antioxidant support for a healthy adult dog.
Alternatives
- [Instinct vs Orijen](/compare/instinct-vs-orijen)
- [Nulo vs Blue Buffalo](/compare/nulo-vs-blue-buffalo)
- [Blue Buffalo vs Wellness](/compare/blue-buffalo-vs-wellness)
FAQ
Is raw-coated kibble actually healthier? It provides freeze-dried raw enzymes and probiotics alongside cooked kibble. Many owners report improved coat and digestion. Measurable benefit varies by dog.
Is Instinct available at Petco? Yes. Instinct is sold at Petco, Chewy, and independent pet stores.
Which is better for puppies? Instinct Puppy has 37% protein with DHA—excellent. Blue Buffalo Puppy is more affordable. Both are AAFCO approved for growth.
Has Instinct been recalled? Nature’s Variety had a 2015 recall of a raw cat food variety. Instinct dog kibble has not been recalled.
Is Instinct worth twice the price of Blue Buffalo? For active or performance dogs, the higher protein and raw coating are meaningful. For sedentary dogs, Blue Buffalo is more cost-effective.
*Disclosure: GetPetPros.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we’ve independently evaluated.*