Ollie Dog Food Review 2026: Is It Worth the Price?

GetPetPros Score: 8.8/10

Category	Score
Ingredient Quality	9.0/10
Nutritional Completeness	9.0/10
Value for Money	8.0/10
Delivery Experience	9.0/10
Customization	8.5/10
Palatability	9.5/10

Quick verdict: Ollie is an excellent fresh dog food subscription — the second-best in the category behind The Farmer’s Dog in most scenarios, and the first choice for dogs that need a fish-based protein or owners who prefer less frequent delivery. The pricing is slightly more competitive than The Farmer’s Dog, and the half-portion option makes it more accessible as a food topper rather than a full diet replacement.

Check Price“>Get started with Ollie →

Company Overview

Ollie was founded in 2016 in New York City by Alex Douzet, Gabby Slome, and Randy Jimenez. The company has raised over $80 million in venture funding and was valued at approximately $300 million in its most recent funding round. Ollie remains independent — unlike Nom Nom (acquired by Purina in 2022), Ollie has not been acquired by a major pet food conglomerate.

Ollie produces all food in USDA human-grade production facilities. Their recipes are formulated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists (DACVN). The company ships to all 50 states and processes approximately 500,000 fresh meals per day at capacity.

Key differentiators vs. The Farmer’s Dog:

Fish recipe (salmon and herring) — unique to Ollie
Lamb recipe for novel protein needs
Half-portion plan option (use as topper)
Slightly lower pricing at comparable serving sizes
Resealable pouches vs. vacuum-sealed (more practical mid-serving)

Recipes and Ingredients

Ollie offers five recipes:

Chicken Recipe

Ingredients: Deboned chicken, peas, chickpeas, sweet potato, chicken liver, kale, sunflower oil, fish oil, dicalcium phosphate, potassium chloride, zinc, Vitamin E, Vitamin B12, thiamine
Protein: ~28% | Fat: ~8% | Calories: ~1,100 kcal/lb

Beef Recipe

Ingredients: USDA ground beef, peas, carrots, green beans, beef liver, spinach, sunflower oil, fish oil, dicalcium phosphate, potassium chloride, zinc, Vitamin E, Vitamin B12, thiamine
Protein: ~26% | Fat: ~9% | Calories: ~1,050 kcal/lb

Turkey Recipe

Ingredients: Turkey, sweet potato, peas, spinach, blueberries, turkey liver, sunflower oil, fish oil, dicalcium phosphate, potassium chloride, zinc, Vitamin E, Vitamin B12
Protein: ~27% | Fat: ~7% | Calories: ~1,000 kcal/lb

Lamb Recipe

Ingredients: Lamb, lamb liver, kale, carrots, peas, blueberries, sunflower oil, fish oil, dicalcium phosphate, potassium chloride, zinc, Vitamin E, Vitamin B12
Protein: ~27% | Fat: ~9% | Calories: ~1,080 kcal/lb

Fish Recipe (Salmon & Herring)

Ingredients: Salmon, herring, sweet potato, peas, spinach, salmon oil, sunflower oil, dicalcium phosphate, potassium chloride, zinc, Vitamin E, Vitamin B12, thiamine
Protein: ~29% | Fat: ~10% | Calories: ~1,100 kcal/lb

Ingredient Quality Assessment

Ollie’s ingredient quality is high by any standard. All protein sources are named whole meats and organ meats. No rendered meals, no artificial preservatives, no synthetic colors. Fish oil is added to all recipes, providing EPA and DHA omega-3s.

One observation: Several Ollie recipes contain peas and chickpeas as significant carbohydrate sources. While the FDA DCM investigation focused primarily on kibble (not fresh food), the legume content is worth noting for breeds with elevated cardiac disease risk (French Bulldogs, Golden Retrievers, Dobermans). The Fish recipe uses salmon oil as the primary fat source and has lower legume content.

Pricing

Ollie pricing is based on the dog’s profile (weight, age, activity level, health conditions). Approximate monthly costs for full-plan feeding:

| Dog Size | Full Plan | Half-Portion Plan |
|———-|———–|——————-|
| 10–15 lbs | ~$35–$55 | ~$18–$28 |
| 30–40 lbs | ~$65–$90 | ~$33–$45 |
| 50–65 lbs | ~$85–$120 | ~$43–$60 |
| 80–100 lbs | ~$130–$180 | ~$65–$90 |

Half-Portion Plan: Ollie’s half-portion option (providing 50% of daily calories from Ollie, supplemented with premium kibble) is a practical middle ground for large dog owners or budget-conscious owners. This approach captures most of the digestibility and palatability benefits of fresh food at a significantly lower cost.

First order discount: Typically 50% off, comparable to The Farmer’s Dog.

Affiliate commission note: Ollie offers ~$60 flat commission per new customer enrollment — one of the highest flat payouts in the pet food category.

The Fish Recipe: A Unique Differentiator

The Farmer’s Dog does not offer a fish-based recipe. Ollie’s Salmon & Herring recipe fills a genuine market need:

Who needs a fish recipe:

Dogs with confirmed allergies to beef, chicken, turkey, and pork (the four most common canine food allergens) — fish is a novel protein for most dogs
Dogs with dry skin or poor coat quality that benefit from direct marine omega-3 sources beyond supplemental fish oil
Owners who specifically want a cold-water fish protein for environmental or health-preference reasons

The Fish recipe delivers 29% protein and uses salmon oil as the primary fat — providing the highest natural EPA/DHA content of any Ollie recipe. For dogs with inflammatory skin conditions or cardiovascular concerns, this is a meaningful advantage.

Delivery Experience

Ollie ships in insulated boxes with dry ice. Food arrives frozen. Key delivery details:

Delivery frequency: Every 1–4 weeks (less frequent than TFD’s maximum 8-week option)
Packaging: Resealable pouches (practical advantage — unused portions seal and refrigerate without transferring to a separate container)
Shelf life: 4 months frozen, 4 days refrigerated after opening
Delivery reliability: Based on customer reviews, delivery is reliable with infrequent complaints about damaged or thawed shipments

Transition guidance: Ollie provides a 7-day transition guide and access to a pet dietitian hotline for customers with questions during transition. This is a customer service differentiator — most fresh food brands don’t offer direct access to nutritional guidance.

Who Ollie Is Best For

Ideal for:

Dogs with multiple protein sensitivities who need a fish-based diet
Dogs needing the novel lamb protein for allergy management
Owners who want a half-portion plan as a cost-effective topper approach
Owners who prefer resealable pouches over vacuum-sealed packaging
Budget-conscious buyers choosing between Ollie and TFD (Ollie is typically 10–15% cheaper)

Not ideal for:

Dogs that specifically need to avoid peas/legumes (several Ollie recipes contain significant legumes)
Owners who need delivery flexibility beyond 4 weeks between shipments (TFD allows up to 8 weeks)
Very large dogs where fresh food cost is prohibitive regardless of brand

Comparing Ollie to Alternatives

| Product | Monthly Cost (50 lb dog) | Fish Recipe | Lamb Recipe | Legume Content |
|———|————————–|————-|————-|—————-|
| Ollie | ~$85–$120 | Yes | Yes | Moderate |
| The Farmer’s Dog | ~$90–$130 | No | No | Low-Moderate |
| Nom Nom | ~$100–$140 | No | No | Low |
| PetPlate | ~$80–$120 | No | Yes | Moderate |

Farmers Dog Vs Ollie“>Compare Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie in detail →

Farmers Dog Vs Ollie — TFD vs Ollie full comparison
Farmers Dog — The Farmer’s Dog review
Nom Nom Vs Petplate — Other fresh food options
French Bulldog — Best food for French Bulldogs
Golden Retriever — Best food for Goldens

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Ollie dog food worth the money?

A: For dogs with digestive issues, poor coat quality, or declining appetite, Ollie (like The Farmer’s Dog) provides measurable improvements that are worth the premium for most owners. For healthy dogs doing well on premium kibble, the clinical evidence for spending 3–5x more is less clear-cut. The half-portion plan at ~$43–$60/month for a 50 lb dog is the most cost-effective way to get fresh food benefits.

Q: How does Ollie compare to The Farmer’s Dog?

A: Both are excellent. The Farmer’s Dog has a slightly cleaner ingredient list and USDA human-grade certification; Ollie has a fish recipe, lamb recipe, and the half-portion option. Ollie is typically 10–15% cheaper. For most dogs, either will produce comparable health outcomes. The choice often comes down to protein needs (fish/lamb needed → Ollie) and price sensitivity (both are similar, with Ollie slightly cheaper).

Q: Is Ollie good for dogs with food allergies?

A: Ollie is an excellent choice for food-allergic dogs. Five distinct recipes using different primary proteins (chicken, beef, turkey, lamb, salmon/herring) provide significant variety for allergy rotation or elimination trial. The Fish recipe specifically is useful for dogs that have been sensitized to the four most common canine allergens (beef, chicken, turkey, dairy).

Q: Does Ollie use human-grade ingredients?

A: Yes. Ollie uses human-grade ingredients in human-grade production facilities — the same standard as The Farmer’s Dog. All Ollie production occurs in facilities that could legally process food for human consumption, not just pet-grade facilities.

Q: How long does Ollie last in the refrigerator after opening?

A: Opened Ollie pouches last 4 days in the refrigerator. Unopened frozen pouches last 4 months. The resealable pouch design allows partial portions to be refrigerated between feedings without transferring to a separate container.

GetPetPros.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Ollie Dog Food Review 2026